5 Best Trolling Reels Reviewed: Maximize Catches

Ever feel lost staring at a wall of fishing reels, wondering which one will actually help you land that big catch? It’s a common feeling for anglers, especially when it comes to trolling reels. These specialized tools are vital for deep-sea fishing, but choosing the wrong one can lead to frustrating tangles, lost fish, and wasted money. You need a reel that handles heavy lines and tough fights without giving up.

The market is flooded with confusing terms like drag ratings and gear ratios. How do you know which features truly matter for your style of trolling? Stop guessing and start mastering your gear! This guide cuts through the jargon. We will break down everything you need to know about Trolling Reels, from size and material to the best features for different waters.

By the end of this post, you will confidently select a Trolling Reel that perfectly matches your needs, ensuring smoother, more successful trolling trips every time. Let’s dive in and discover the perfect reel for your next adventure!

Top Trolling Reel Recommendations

No. 1
Shakespeare ATS Size 20 Conventional Trolling Fishing Reel, Right Handle Position
  • SHAKESPEARE ATS CONVENTIONAL TROLLING REEL: Made with lightweight, durable graphite materials, ATS conventional trolling reels deliver performance and reliability.
  • RECOVERY RATE: Recover 26" | 66cm of line with every turn of the crank. Gear ratio of 5.1:1. Right handle position. Line counter and non-line counter options available for each reel size.
  • 2 BALL BEARINGS: Enjoy an effortless casting experience with a stainless steel level wind system and 2 ball bearings for smooth gear feel. Built for freshwater applications.
  • MULTI-DISC DRAG SYSTEM: Our dependable multi-disc drag system provides a consistent and reliable star drag. Featuring a max drag of 15lb | 6.8kg to help tire out the fish.
  • SINCE 1897, Shakespeare has been the leader in quality, affordable fishing tackle. With 115 years of passion and experience, we offer something for the whole family and to all levels of experience.
No. 2
Okuma Magda Pro Line Counter Levelwind Trolling Reel, Small, Black/Silver, MA-20DXT
  • Magda Pro Size 20 - 5.1:1 Gear Ratio
  • Multi-Disc Carbonite Drag System
  • 2 Stainless Steel Ball Bearings
  • Lightweight Corrosion Resistant Frame And Side Plates
No. 3
SAMOLLA Baitcasting Fishing Reel 8 oz Ultralight Smart Digital Baitcaster Reels with 22 Lb Max Drag 7.2:1 High-Speed Gear Ratio Right Handed Freshwater Saltwater Compact Design Silver TX900
  • SAMOLLA digital fishing reel: Real-time Data Monitoring & Display:Instantly track key fishing metrics including wire length, water depth, temperature, and retrieval speed on a clear screen. Stay informed and adjust your strategy in real time for a more efficient fishing experience
  • Electric fishing reel SAMOLLA: Smart Fishing Alarms & Bait Protection:Get alerted immediately with the fishing alarm function when a fish bites. The bait close-range alarm beeps when bait is within 3m/5m of the boat, preventing loss and saving tackle
  • SAMOLLA baitcasting reel:One-Click Reset & Multi-Line Selection:Quickly recover from breaks with the wire breakage reset function. Choose from PE2# to PE8# wire types for versatile use in both freshwater and saltwater conditions
  • Baitcaster reels SAMOLLA: Night Fishing Ready & Energy Saving:Equipped with a night background light for clear visibility after dark. The auto screen-off feature conserves battery, ensuring longer trips without power worries
  • Long-Lasting & Weather-Aware:Monitor remaining battery level in real time and check live temperature updates. Built for endurance and adaptability, so you’re always prepared on the water
No. 4
Shakespeare ATS Size 15 Conventional Trolling Fishing Reel, Right Handle Position
  • SHAKESPEARE ATS CONVENTIONAL TROLLING REEL: Made with lightweight, durable graphite materials, ATS conventional trolling reels deliver performance and reliability.
  • RECOVERY RATE: Recover 26" | 66cm of line with every turn of the crank. Gear ratio of 5.1:1. Right handle position. Line counter and non-line counter options available for each reel size.
  • 2 BALL BEARINGS: Enjoy an effortless casting experience with a stainless steel level wind system and 2 ball bearings for smooth gear feel. Built for freshwater applications.
  • MULTI-DISC DRAG SYSTEM: Our dependable multi-disc drag system provides a consistent and reliable star drag. Featuring a max drag of 15lb | 6.8kg to help tire out the fish.
  • SINCE 1897, Shakespeare has been the leader in quality, affordable fishing tackle. With 115 years of passion and experience, we offer something for the whole family and to all levels of experience.
No. 5
Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-153D
  • Made using the highest quality materials
  • Tested for reliability and quality
  • Used by professionals worldwide
  • Lightweight corrosion resistant frame and side plates
  • Multi disc Carbonite drag system
No. 6
Sougayilang Trolling Reel Level Wind Conventional Reel Graphite Body Fishing Reel, Durable Stainless-Steel, Large Line Capacity-DTR40 Left Handle
  • EXCELLENT COMPONENTS -- The VICTOR S uses the best components, Its pinion gear and line guide shaft are high quality stainless-steel. Dual Anti-reverse System and Full Carbonite Drag System providing Extreme Durability and Long-term Alignment of Gears and Shafts, and the super durable light weight graphite corrosion-resistant Frame & Side-plates.
  • POWERFUL DRAG -- The round casting reels use a smooth, carbon disc drag that delivers 32 lbs of fish stopping power. The Round Conventional Baitcasting Reel will be perfect for Salmon, Steelhead, Trout, Kokanee, Walleye, Lake Trout, Striped Bass, saltwater or freshwater species and so much.
  • SPECIFIC PARAMETERS -- 3+1 stainless-steel ball bearings, the gear ratio is 4.1:1. The aluminum handle arm has stronger strength, the great line capacity(mm/M): 0.45-399 0.50-295, LBS/YDS: 25-390, 30-300
  • HIGH APPEARANCE -- The new arrival of Sougayilang is VICTOR S which is designed to suit both the saltwater and freshwater fishing ground. It can provide you the most perfect experience with its matte black and dark red performance. A wonderful gift for your friends, husband, father, boy friend.
  • 3 YEARS SUPPORT -- We give 100% heart to our customers, so whatever the problem you have, as long as you ask for help about our products, Sougayilang will help you solve it within 24 hours!
No. 7
Burning Shark Trolling Reel Saltwater Level Wind Reels, Drag Reels Boat Fishing Ocean Fishing for Sea Bass Grouper Salmon-SHA40
  • 【Heavy-Duty Saltwater Performance】Engineered for big game fishing, the Burning Shark SHA40 conventional reel boasts a solid metal body with 6+1 stainless steel ball bearings, delivering ultra-smooth retrieves even under 40 lbs of max drag. Its corrosion-resistant construction and Carbonite drag system ensure relentless performance in saltwater conditions. 
  • 【Precision Trolling & Level Wind Control】 Designed for trolling enthusiasts, this level wind reel features a 4.1:1 gear ratio for optimal speed-to-power balance. The built-in line guide evenly distributes braid or monofilament, eliminating tangles during long-distance drops—perfect for targeting pelagic species. 
  • 【Ergonomic & Fatigue-Free Handling】 Weighing just 23 oz (640g), the SHA40 reduces wrist strain during extended battles. The anti-reverse roller bearing locks instantly on hooksets, while the star drag’s aluminum alloy knob provides micro-adjustments for fighting trophy fish.
  • 【Pro-Grade Value Don’t overpay for performance.】 The SHA40 packs tournament-ready specs—like a forged aluminum spool and double-dog anti-reverse—at a fraction of the cost. Whether you’re trolling for kings or bottom fishing for grouper, this reel earns its keep.
  • 【3-Year Worry Free 】 Backed by Burning Shark’s 3-year limited service, this reel is a long-term investment for anglers who demand reliability. Packed with pro-grade features at a mid-range price, it’s a saltwater workhorse that won’t quit.
No. 8
Sougayilang Line Counter Fishing Reel Conventional Level Wind Trolling Reel-TRA 30R
  • DURABLE: The entire TRA 30R line counter reel is based upon a powerful star drag foundation, supported by heavy duty brass gears and a full Carbonite drag system. With the ability to output 20 lbs. of drag, this particular reel model is incredibly powerful. As an additional benefit, the Aluminum ratcheting drag star enables trolling fishermen to set precise drag settings.
  • EASY OPERATION: One of the absolute best things about this trolling reel is the fact that it fits so comfortably in your hand, which is great for anglers who plan on staying out on the water for a long time. There is also a very smooth drag, which is obviously one of the more important things to consider when shopping for a fishing reel of any kind. The anti-reverse roller bearings work very well, and the overall build is exceptionally solid. If you want a durable reel, this is the one for you.
  • FASTER SET-UP: Each time you check your lure, or better yet, reel in a fish, you'll want to get your line back into the strike zone as quick as possible. If the fish struck at 100' of line out behind the boat, just flip the reel into free-spool and let line spool out until the line counter hits 100'. This is much faster and more accurate than pulling line off the reel by hand and counting number of pulls.
  • WORTHFUL-It may not be the very best reel on the market, but you will most defiantly get your money’s worth out of this one. From your pals at fishing tips guru we are always wishing you the best on the water and happy and safe fishing experience.
  • THREE-YEARS Worry-Free Service: This fishing reel is backed by a three-year Worry-Free Service, so you will be able to get any replacements or repairs you need within this period of time.

Choosing Your Next Trolling Reel: A Buyer’s Guide

Trolling fishing is a fantastic way to cover a lot of water and find big fish. Whether you are chasing big tuna offshore or landlocked salmon, the right trolling reel makes all the difference. This guide helps you pick the perfect reel for your next adventure.

Key Features to Look For

A great trolling reel needs specific features to handle the stress of dragging lures all day. Think about these important parts when you shop.

1. Gear Ratio

  • What it is: This tells you how fast the spool spins with every turn of the handle.
  • Why it matters: A lower gear ratio (like 3.2:1) gives you more cranking power for heavy loads. A higher ratio (like 5.1:1) lets you retrieve your line faster when you need to check your lure or fight a fast runner.

2. Drag System

  • What it is: The drag controls how much pressure the reel puts on the fish before the line starts peeling out.
  • Why it matters: You need a smooth, powerful drag. Look for reels with “carbon fiber” or “HD (Heavy Duty)” drag washers. Jerky drags spook fish and can snap your line.

3. Line Capacity

  • What it is: How much fishing line the spool can hold.
  • Why it matters: Offshore trolling often means long runs from big fish. Make sure the reel holds enough heavy-test line (like 50lb or 80lb mono or braid) for the fish you target.

Important Materials Matter

The materials used decide how long your reel lasts and how much punishment it can take.

Frame and Sideplates

  • Aluminum: Most high-quality trolling reels use machined aluminum frames. Aluminum is strong and resists bending under heavy pressure. It also handles saltwater spray well if it has good coatings.
  • Composite/Graphite: Some lighter reels use strong composite materials. These reduce weight, which helps when trolling for many hours. Quality is key here; cheap composite breaks easily.

Bearings

  • Stainless Steel: Always choose stainless steel bearings, especially for saltwater use. They resist rust better than standard steel. More sealed bearings usually mean smoother operation.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Not all reels are built the same. Small details separate the top-tier reels from the budget options.

What Makes a Reel Better

  • One-Piece Frame: A single, solid frame is much stronger than a frame made of several bolted-together pieces.
  • Anodizing: Good anodizing seals the aluminum against corrosion. This finish keeps the reel looking new and functioning smoothly for years.
  • Ratcheting Drag Lever: High-end reels have a precise lever system that lets you set the drag exactly where you want it, from Free Spool to Full Strike.

What Lowers Quality

  • Plastic Components: If the handle knobs, drag lever, or spool are made of cheap plastic, they will likely fail first.
  • Poor Sealing: Reels that lack good seals around the bearings and drag washers let water and salt seep inside. This causes corrosion and sticking parts.

User Experience and Use Cases

Think about where and how you fish. This affects the size and style of reel you need.

Offshore Big Game (Tuna, Marlin)

You need large reels (50W or 80W class). These demand high drag pressure (30+ lbs) and huge line capacity. Durability is the top priority here.

Inshore/Lake Trolling (Trout, Salmon, Smaller Stripers)

Smaller reels (like 20 or 30 size) work well. Focus on smooth retrieves and lighter weight for all-day use. A faster gear ratio can be nice for quickly resetting lines.

Single Speed vs. Two Speed

  • Single Speed: Simpler and usually tougher. You pick one gear ratio.
  • Two Speed: These let you switch gears instantly. Use the low gear for fighting heavy fish and the high gear for faster retrieval. They add complexity but offer versatility.

Trolling Reel Buying Guide: 10 Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What size trolling reel should I buy?

A: Reel size is based on line class. For small fish, look at 15-30 size reels. For big offshore fish, you need 50, 80, or 130 size reels.

Q: Is a two-speed reel always better than a single-speed reel?

A: No. Two-speed reels offer flexibility but have more moving parts that can fail. If you only need power, a high-quality single speed works great.

Q: What is the most important part of a trolling reel?

A: The drag system is the most critical part. A smooth, strong drag prevents line breaks when a big fish makes a sudden run.

Q: Do I need a reel with clicker or alarm?

A: Yes, most serious trollers prefer a loud clicker. This alarm sounds when a fish hits your line while you are looking away or busy rigging another rod.

Q: Can I use a conventional reel for trolling?

A: Yes, conventional reels are the standard for trolling. Spinning reels are generally too light for the heavy demands of trolling.

Q: How do I clean my trolling reel after saltwater use?

A: Immediately rinse the entire reel thoroughly with fresh, running water. Do not spray directly into the drag or bearing areas. Dry it completely afterward.

Q: What does “pre-spooled” mean?

A: It means the reel comes already filled with fishing line from the factory. Check the line type and test weight before buying.

Q: How does the gear ratio affect trolling?

A: A lower ratio (like 3.0:1) gives you more lifting power to fight heavy fish. A higher ratio (like 4.5:1) lets you reel in your lure faster between passes.

Q: Should I choose braided line or monofilament for trolling?

A: Braid holds more line in a smaller space and has no stretch, which helps set the hook. Many trollers use braid backing and top it off with a few yards of mono leader.

Q: How often should I service my trolling reel?

A: If you fish saltwater frequently, you should service the reel (lubricate and check drag washers) at least once a year. If you notice grinding noises, service it sooner.