Top 5 Insoles for Baseball Cleats: Comfort & Performance

Ever feel like your feet are screaming after a long game in your baseball cleats? You’re not alone. Many ballplayers struggle with uncomfortable cleats, leading to sore arches, tired legs, and maybe even blisters. Finding the right insole can change everything, turning painful practices into powerful performances.

Choosing the perfect insole for your baseball cleats is tricky business. Do you need extra arch support? Should you focus on cushioning or stability? The market is flooded with choices, and the wrong pick can actually make your game worse, not better. It’s frustrating when you spend money but still end up with aching feet by the ninth inning.

This guide cuts through the confusion. We will break down exactly what makes a great baseball cleat insole. You will learn about different materials, key features like shock absorption, and how to match an insole to your specific foot needs. Get ready to discover the secret weapon for better comfort and more explosive plays on the diamond.

Top Insoles For Baseball Cleats Recommendations

Bestseller No. 1
CURREX CLEATPRO - Thin, Arch Support Insoles, Comfort, Cushion & Stability in Cleats, Soccer, Football, Baseball, Softball, Super Grip for Control, Shock Absorbing Inserts, Men, Women (Medium Arch, M)
  • FEEL BETTER, PERFORM BETTER: Flexible support and shock absorbing cushioning from heel to toe help reduce fatigue, prevent common sports injuries for uninterrupted play, and boost performance with rapid acceleration and precision turns; a decoupled heel cup creates a secure fit, wrap and lock in narrow cleats and spikes for greater heel stability
  • 3D Dynamic Arch Technology & SuperGrip Anti-slip: Our dynamic arch support insoles come in low, medium and high arch support profiles; they feature a deep decoupled heel cup and anti-slip surface that keeps the foot perfectly connected with the shoe for complete control on any field
  • Engineered to Keep You on the Field: Shock absorbing forefoot cushioning and maximum flexibility underfoot delivers explosive propulsion with every stride; insoles can be trimmed for a perfect fit, so you can take your game to the next level of performance with comfort, stability, and control
  • Moisture Management & Breathability: The insert’s bamboo midlayer helps manage moisture and the odor absorbing premium foam cushioning keeps your feet dry and cleats fresh all day long; note you should replace your CURREX insoles after 500+ miles or when the top layer shows signs of significant wear
  • Made for What Moves You: CURREX is the only insole company that offers a full line of activity-specific insoles customized to help improve how you move; whatever you or your family loves to do, from the workday through the weekend, CURREX makes moving more comfortable, leading to better performance and more fun
Bestseller No. 2
MOVE Baseline - All-Purpose Insoles - Sock Liner - Ultra Thin Shock Absorption - Maximum Freedom of Movement and Energy Return for Cleats, Shoes, Running, Basketball, Baseball (M11-11.5/WM12.5-13)
  • BASELINE: is a versatile insole perfect for game day and all day. The perfect insole for people who want the comfort, responsiveness, and shock absorption of a Move insole with a neutral support profile.
  • SUPPORT: Baseline neutral support profile is designed for wearers who want maximum freedom of movement and minimal prescriptive support.
  • MoveX FOAM: Shock absorption to reduce fatigue, upgraded comfort, prevent injury, ultra light weight, maximum bounce and performance-graded energy return, and durable. Baseline insoles are moulded from a single material with no adhesives. Plush cushioned feel that doesn't wear out over time.
  • LOW PROFILE: Provides pro-level benefits without adding bulk to sneakers.
  • ZERO DROP: A more neutral feel for greater freedom of movement and enhanced connection with the ground.
Bestseller No. 3
MOVE Game Day Pro- Ultimate Performance Sports Insoles for Basketball, Volleyball, Football, Tennis, Athletics, Baseball, Running, and Active Lifestyle. Extra Shock Absorption (M 10-10.5/WM 11.5-12)
  • ULTIMATE PERFORMANCE INSOLE: Experience the vibrant adaptability of Game Day Pro insoles. They mold to your shoe, foot, and playing style, offering a solid, responsive foundation for takeoff and a plush, cushioned landing. Game Day Pro ensures stability while enhancing your natural foot movement, ready to elevate your performance every time you step onto the field or court.
  • TRUSTED BY THE PROS: Co-founded by NBA All-Pro Damian Lillard, Move's Game Day Pro insole is the choice of countless professional athletes across various sports. Join the ranks of elite performers who rely on Game Day Pro for peak performance and injury prevention.
  • FOOT PAIN RELIEF & PREVENTION: Say goodbye to discomfort with Game Day Pro insoles. Boasting high arch support, they combat Plantar Fasciitis and alleviate stress and pain from common foot ailments like flat feet and Achilles Tendonitis. Whether you're working, standing, or playing sports, enjoy enhanced control and performance.
  • X-FRAME TORSIONAL SUPPORT: Get the protection and agility you need with Game Day Pro's heel and midfoot support. Its design ensures stability while facilitating maximum movement, empowering you to perform with confidence.
  • ACTIVE HEEL TECHNOLOGY: Game Day Pro's Active Heel Technology targets pressure points in sensitive areas, delivering unparalleled comfort during extended wear, so you can focus on your game without distractions.
SaleBestseller No. 4
Sof Sole Cleat Speed Insole– Slim Profile, Anti-Slip Friction Pads for Faster Cuts, Custom Fit, Enhanced Performance in Football, Soccer, Lacrosse, and Baseball Cleats– Moisture-Wicking, Men's 7-13
  • Reduces Foot Slippage in Cleats: Strategically placed friction pads keep your foot securely in place, reducing unwanted movement in cleated footwear.
  • Improves Reaction Time: Friction pads promote faster pressure transfer, allowing athletes to react more quickly and make faster cuts on the field.
  • Ultra-Slim Profile: The slim-profile design ensures a snug, comfortable fit in low-volume cleated footwear without adding bulk.
  • Prevents Insole Movement: The wave grip foam base keeps the insole securely in place inside the cleats, ensuring consistent support during athletic activity.
  • Moisture-Wicking Comfort: The polyester top cover wicks away moisture, helping to keep feet cooler and more comfortable during play, while the trim-to-fit sizing allows for a customized fit.
Bestseller No. 5
VKTRY Gold for Cleated Shoes - Carbon Fiber Performance Insoles Customized Athletic Inserts for Football, Baseball, Soccer, Golf, Lax & More | Run Fast, Jump High, US M12-12.5, W14-14.5, 171-220lb
  • Carbon Fiber Technology: Made from 100% aerospace-grade carbon fiber, VKTRY Gold Performance Insoles deliver optimal shock absorption and energy return; engineered to support powerful takeoffs, stable landings, and consistent comfort during high-impact training. Best for sports like football, baseball, lacrosse, soccer, golf and other athletic games.
  • Engineered for Explosiveness: Built to maximize energy return and responsiveness for explosive movements; supports lower-body alignment and stability during sprints, cuts, jumps, and running, and helps manage fatigue during intense training and competitive matches.
  • Customized Comfort & Support For Athletes: Precision-tailored by sport, gender, and weight for customized arch support insoles, stability, and cushioned comfort. Featuring a sport-specific carbon fiber baseplate that matches energy output and enhances strong pushoffs, helping athletes achieve peak performance.
  • Data-Backed Performance Insights: Independent third-party testing at Southern Connecticut State University (SCSU) showed athletes experienced an average improvement of 9.3% in explosiveness, 2% faster 10-yard sprint speeds, and a 1.1-inch increase in vertical jumps compared to standard athletic insoles. (Results based on a study of 34 NCAA athletes vs. stock foam insoles; individual results may vary.)
  • Suitable For Cleated Shoes: Compatible with most cleated athletic footwear, VKTRY shock absorption insoles provide energy return, responsive cushioning, and stability during dynamic movements like running, jumping, and sprinting; engineered to support high-impact actions, explosive leaping, and secure landings with added grip for enhanced stability. Easily slips into athletic footware like football cleats.
Bestseller No. 6
OUPOWER Soccer Cleat Insoles Insert Gen3-Slim Thickenss Green Tornado (US9.5-10)
  • Ergonomically designed OUPOWER soccer cleats insoles insoles provide excellent cushioning, thumb and finger bone collapses in volume, more flexibility in running and preventing rollover
  • 【Anti-slippery 3D embossing patterns】By collecting professional soccer players feedback, OUPOWER soccer cleats insoles upgraded our insoles with anti-slippery embossments and additional toe carved fit design.
  • 【Breathable and cool feet】OUPOWER soccer cleats insoles Breathable holes are made on the forefoot to allow air to circulate, quickly absorb moisture, and keep the feet dry and fresh.
  • 【Specially designed for professional soccer players】OUPOWER soccer cleats insoles Verified and tested by thousands of soccer players, our product enhances your soccer cleat to a higher performance level.
Bestseller No. 7
MASTERFIT EZQF Stride Low Volume Sport Insoles for Men - Sports Insoles for Cleats, Easily Trimmed Cleat Inserts for Soccer, Running, Hiking, Baseball, Softball, Football – Stride Regular Volume, L
  • ERGONOMIC SUPPORT SHELL FOR BALANCE AND STABILITY: Our EZQF Stride running insoles are designed to provide active men with the stability they need for sports and work environments. Enjoy improved performance in every step, whether hiking, or playing with this basketball insoles. Experience the difference as your posture and alignment are enhanced, reducing the risk of injury over time. These soccer insoles for cleats are available in various sizes to ensure a perfect fit.
  • MEMORY FOAM COMFORT CRADLE FOR CUSTOMIZED CUSHIONING: With our athletic insoles, you'll feel the superior cushioning tailored to every unique contour of your feet. Avoid discomfort caused by flat insoles for running shoes that don't adapt to your foot shape. This adaptive feature of our insoles for soccer cleats not only ensures a snug fit but also provides exceptional comfort, for prolonged physical activities without the usual exhaustion.
  • HEEL & ARCH SUPPORT FOR ORTHOPEDIC FIT: Our running shoe insoles offer comprehensive heel and arch support, addressing common issues like plantar fasciitis and heel spurs. Active men often experience soreness due to inadequate support, but our volleyball insoles alleviate these challenges by offering an orthopedic fit. Enjoy a healthier stride and reduce long-term foot issues, making this a vital choice for both sports and work performance insoles for cleats.
  • CUSHIONING PLATFORMS FOR SHOCK ABSORPTION: Protect your feet from the constant impact of daily activities with our athletic insoles for cleats. Each step is absorbed, minimizing stress on joints and reducing potential pain. Whether you are hitting the gym or airing through work shifts, feel the energy transfer from platform to foot, improving endurance and comfort. This feature of our soccer cleat insoles extends footwear life by absorbing impact that would otherwise wear out shoes quickly.
  • ODOR AND MOISTURE CONTROL FOR FRESHNESS: Keep your feet fresh throughout the day with our insoles for running shoes men with advanced odor and moisture management technology. Many basketball insoles men fail to address foot odor, but ours excel in this area, ensuring your feet stay dry and free from unpleasant smells. Enjoy the confidence of fresh feet with our insoles for basketball shoes, whether you’re on a long hike or a busy workday.
SaleBestseller No. 8
PowerStep Pulse Thin Orthotics, Arch Support Inserts, Pain Relief for Cleats & Tight Running Shoes, Insoles for Plantar Fasciitis Relief, Mild Pronation, Shin Splints, Unisex , Made in the USA
  • Full-Length, Thin Profile - These arch support insoles for running and athletic activity cover the entire length of your foot for added support. Great for running shoes, cleats, spikes, golf, cycling, and casual low-profile/narrow, and tight shoes.
  • Firm But Flexible Arch Support - Our arch relief insoles feature a deep heel support cradle for increased comfort and stability, as well as a non slip pad to hold the orthotic in place. The contoured arch support insert is a unique PowerStep design.
  • Premium ShockAbsorb™ Foam Technology - Not found in ordinary work boot insoles, our ShockAbsorb Foam in these running orthotics provides bounce-back with each step while, like memory foam, absorbing shock at impact to reduce stress on the feet, ankles, joints, and tendons.
  • The Perfect Balance of Comfort and Support - These running insoles for men and women double as orthotics for plantar fasciitis and they help to stabilize and align the feet for plantar fasciitis relief as well as mild to moderate pronation. This shoe insole strikes the perfect balance!
  • No Trimming Required - Moveable from shoe to shoe with no trimming required, these arch support insoles for women and men can be worn in a wide variety of athletic shoes. Unlike many insoles for flat feet and feet pain relief products, these come ready to wear. The majority of our insoles and orthotics for women and men are designed and produced in the USA at our Ohio facility.

The Ultimate Buying Guide for Baseball Cleat Insoles

Stepping onto the baseball diamond requires the right gear. Your cleats are essential, but what about what’s inside them? Good insoles can seriously boost your comfort, performance, and protection. This guide helps you pick the best insoles for your baseball cleats.

Key Features to Look For

When shopping for insoles, keep these important features in mind. They make a big difference in how you play.

1. Arch Support

  • What it is: This part of the insole cradles the middle of your foot.
  • Why it matters: Good arch support keeps your foot properly aligned. This stops pain in your feet, ankles, and even your knees after a long game. Some insoles offer neutral support, while others offer high or low support. Choose what matches your natural foot shape.

2. Cushioning and Shock Absorption

  • What it is: This is the soft material that absorbs impact.
  • Why it matters: Baseball involves a lot of running, jumping, and quick stops. Strong shock absorption protects your joints from hard impacts on the field. Look for thicker heel cushioning.

3. Stability and Heel Cup

  • What it is: The heel cup is the bowl shape around your heel.
  • Why it matters: A deep, firm heel cup locks your foot into the cleat. This stops your foot from sliding around inside the shoe during fast lateral movements. Stability prevents blisters and wasted energy.

4. Moisture Wicking

  • What it is: Materials that pull sweat away from your skin.
  • Why it matters: Your feet sweat a lot when you play hard. Moisture-wicking tops keep your feet dry. Dry feet mean fewer blisters and less odor.

Important Materials Used in Insoles

The material an insole uses greatly affects its feel and durability.

Foams and Rubbers
  • EVA (Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate): This is a very common, lightweight foam. It offers good, soft cushioning. It is light, which players love.
  • PU (Polyurethane): This material is denser and more durable than EVA. It often provides better long-term support and shock absorption.
  • Gel Inserts: Gel pads are often placed in high-impact zones like the heel. They offer targeted, superior shock absorption.
Cover Fabrics

The top layer should be durable and breathable. Look for synthetic blends that move sweat away quickly. Some high-end insoles use antimicrobial treatments to fight bacteria that cause bad smells.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Not all insoles are created equal. Quality depends on how they are built.

Factors That Improve Quality:

  • Rigid Support Shells: High-quality insoles often have a firm plastic or carbon fiber base under the foam. This shell maintains the insole’s shape over time, giving you consistent support.
  • Targeted Density: Good manufacturers use softer foam in the forefoot for comfort and firmer foam in the arch and heel for structure.

Factors That Reduce Quality:

  • Thin, Cheap Foam: If the insole feels like a simple piece of soft sponge, it will flatten quickly. This means you lose all your support after only a few weeks of hard use.
  • Lack of Structure: Insoles that are just flat pieces of foam offer little to no actual arch support. They only provide minimal padding.

User Experience and Use Cases

Your specific needs on the field dictate the best insole choice.

For Power Hitters and Base Runners:

These players need maximum energy return and stability. Look for a semi-rigid insole with good heel lock. This ensures that the power from your legs transfers directly into the ground when you swing or sprint.

For Fielders and Pitchers:

Pitchers put massive stress on their lead leg. Fielders make sharp cuts. These users benefit most from excellent shock absorption in the heel and midfoot to reduce joint strain over many innings.

Addressing Common Issues:

If you already have flat feet, you must choose an insole specifically designed for high or deep arch support. If you suffer from plantar fasciitis (heel pain), look for insoles that emphasize deep heel cradling and firm, consistent arch contact.


10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Baseball Cleat Insoles

Q: Do I need insoles if my cleats came with factory insoles?

A: Yes, factory insoles are usually very basic padding. Upgrading gives you better arch support, more cushioning, and better durability for intense play.

Q: Will insoles make my cleats fit too tightly?

A: Sometimes. If your cleats already fit snugly, a thick insole might make them too tight. You might need to remove the thin factory insole first, or consider buying a slightly larger cleat size.

Q: How often should I replace my baseball insoles?

A: Most high-quality insoles last one full season of regular use. If you notice cushioning feeling flat or support collapsing, it is time for a new pair.

Q: Can I use running shoe insoles in my cleats?

A: You can try, but it is not ideal. Running insoles focus on forward motion. Baseball insoles need more lateral (side-to-side) stability for cutting and pivoting.

Q: What is the main benefit of an insole for a pitcher?

A: Pitchers need superior shock absorption on the landing foot to protect the knee and ankle joints from the high forces generated during the windup.

Q: Are custom orthotics better than off-the-shelf insoles?

A: Custom orthotics are molded specifically for your foot by a doctor, offering the best support. Off-the-shelf insoles are a great, affordable alternative that works for most players.

Q: Do insoles help with foot odor?

A: Yes, if they have moisture-wicking or antimicrobial materials. They keep the environment inside your cleat drier and cleaner.

Q: Should I buy a hard or soft insole?

A: Most players benefit from a semi-rigid insole. This means it has a firm structure for support but soft cushioning on top for comfort.

Q: Do insoles help reduce blisters?

A: They greatly help. By stopping your foot from sliding around inside the cleat, they reduce the friction that causes blisters.

Q: Are these insoles washable?

A: Most synthetic insoles can be hand-washed gently with mild soap and air-dried. Never put them in a machine dryer, as the heat can ruin the foam structure.